Dec 11 2008
Putting Vet Back in VA
Sunday, President-elect Barack Obama selected former Army Chief and retired Gen. Eric Shinseki as his secretary of VA.
Shinseki might be best remembered for smashing to the 15 Minutes of Fame Rule. He became a folk hero of sorts following his candid and accurate estimate of troop levels necessary to secure Iraq following combat operations.
In early 2003, while Army chief of staff, Shinseki testified before the Senate Armed Service Committee. In his professional estimate, he told lawmakers several hundred thousand ground troops would be needed to secure Iraq. (Oddly, now fact as folklore, his estimate is pegged a “premonition.” We call it doing his job and knowing his business.) After they revived the Office of the Secretary of Defense denizens, Defense leaders and their goons made the media rounds. Shinseki had taken on a new title: Pariah. While he was not fired or forced out (another part of the folklore), his last few months seemed unpleasant. Shinseki has said little, though for many years, media types and Iraqi Freedom critics have pointed to Shinseki’s troop estimate.
This should be a welcome change for the 66 year old who hails from Hawaii. While at the VA, Shinseki might not be doing much in the area of national security, but his talents will be put to good use. As the story goes, following Vietnam, Shinseki was one of a handful of soldiers badly injured in combat (he lost a portion of his foot to a mine) who successfully fought to remain on active duty. Not only did he overcome his injuries and become the first Asian-American four-star, he can be credited with the roots of the Army’s transformation to a modernized and more responsive force. It was Shinseki who brought magic to the black beret, a simple piece of cloth that gave dignity back to the often downtrodden service.
Shinseki is walking into a generally well-run VA. He will have the opportunity to lead it through the additional load leaders anticipate — medically and otherwise.
Welcome back, Mr. Secretary!
A number of blogs announced Shinseki’s return to the national stage. Posts are fact-based; comments are positive and welcoming.
“While he was not fired or forced out (another part of the folklore) [1], his last few months seemed unpleasant [2].”
1 – A distinction without a difference.
2 – The most notable understatement I’ve seen in a decade or more. It approaches Brit levels.
The Pres-Elect seems to have hit at least 2, mebbe 2-1/2. out of 3 [3 of 4 if you're inclined to count the SecDef] on military selections to date.
Regards,
OJ
[Alright, some ring-knockers have earned my respect. ;->]
OJ -
There has been much debate on what went on with Gen. Shinseki following his testimony. Shinseki as folkhero is surrounded by urban legends. They could not fire him, but they could belittle him and make his life hell. I wish him the best, and I hope he enjoys his new post.
As you’ve read, Jim Jones is a fab choice for national security advisor. Shinseki – thrilled for him. You may have read I have some questions on the Caldera appointmet, though I’m sure no one cares about our observations. He was not one of our best CSAs and his SIX YEARS on the IndyMac Bank Board. (there until they closed the lgihts) is of interest. I don’t think he’s a registered lobbyist, so I guess it makes everything ok.
Enough. Thank for reading and commenting.
Gina
I am thrilled with the choice of GEN Shinseki to head the VA. I was at the Pentagon during his tenure and I worked with Gen Shinseki and his staff on a number of occasions. He was always gracious and professional during briefings. Even when asking the hard questions.
We all knew that he wouldn’t be lasting long after his testimony just as many knew that he was right. Many knew that he was right, but not many spoke up. Some people (SecDefs) just “can’t handle the truth” to steal a phrase from the “Sloane” entry. He is a soldeir’s soldier and a man I would follow into battle with out queston. I’m not an Obama fan nor do I imagine myself jumping on the bandwagon any time soon, but I will say that the President-elect gets big points for this choice in my book.
LOST HOPE FOR FAIR & EQUAL TREATMENT FOR VIETNAM VETERANS LIVING IN MAINLAND SOUTEAST ASIA
I am a Vietnam veteran suffering from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) among other things. Some adjudicated and service-connected and some not. I have no more hope that our government or those in power that can would correct their erroneous policy towards us Vietnam veterans living in Mainland Southeast Asia. I have been confronting the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) about this issue over the last seven (7) years to no avail. We have been written off as a casualty of war when it comes to receiving our earned medical benefits. Some consider us as a small group that they do not have to care about. The VA tells us, we do not deserve these medical benefits beyond the Foreign Medical Program (FMP) because we “chose to live there.” Outside our country and in a place where we fought a war and feel drawn to. Even if the prior statement was so as they put it we still deserve our medical treatment here at the expense of the VA. This is a place where we feel comfortable and at home. This is not taking anything away from our country. I love my country; I just feel that I have to be here. They, the VA, do not care that we are uninsurable in the private market, both locally here in Thailand and internationally, because of our service-connected disabilities.
We would like some to understand that we are just like them. We are the one that was in the foxhole beside you that was the reason you walked out of there. We were the brother that went so you would not have to go. We were the one who willingly risked our life to pull you out of that rice paddy and put you on a Medivac. We were the one who fought our fear and took that stand when we had to. We were the one who stared death in the face, laughed to protect our sanity and went on to perform our duty. Some of us find ourselves mentally still there in the bush. We were in the bush, we have never left the bush and at this age we never will. I am not saying or insinuating we are living in corrugated steel & plywood shacks here in the middle of rice paddies with no running water or electricity and using outhouses to do our business. Though I have heard of that on an occasion or two. The majority of us are living in contemporary housing and feed ourselves well. All we ask is that you take care of us medically, as you would have on those long ago battlefields, which we seem to be stuck in, as we would take care of you.
Here I am standing on the edge of an enigma. I need my medical coverage and I need the comfort of being here. I have always been, I am and will always be proud to have served my country. So why cannot my country be proud to take care of me here and now?
Some of us have joined the local VFW posts; that in a way helps us cope. Others want to be as far away from any structured organization as possible. Veterans have suffered and died here due to lack of proper and sufficient medical care. The facilities are available but sometimes our funds are not. What is the VA waiting for, us to reach the suicidal status before they wake up and admit that we truly have a problem here? And how many will it take before the VA admits that it has erred? I dread to count. Some VA representatives may be happy because there is one or some less left to complain. We are the residual of the Indo-China War here. And just because tourist come to Thailand and some places in Indo-China to vacation does not change that fact.
I fret to think what will happen to me with a catastrophic illness or injury, faced with a 500,000 or one million Baht medical bill and it can not immediately be determined as or is not service-connected. I can no longer afford to do as I have done over the years, and other veterans can not afford too, to go to Honolulu at an average cost of U.S.$5,000 annually to get my medical treatment from the VA and get my life preserving prescriptions renewed. They, the VA representatives, in essence, tell us, if we stay here in Mainland Southeast Asia we can continue to suffer from the lack of proper medical treatment related to issues outside of FMP and die but it is not their problem and we are not “ABANDONED.”
This is all besides the fact that we are not asking the VA to requisition additional funds from Congress to take care of us. We are aware that every fiscal budget approved by Congress contains funds for us, beyond FMP, since we are part of the headcount the VA uses in calculating and requesting funds. We are hoping to be allowed to use those funds here at qualified medical facilities for our necessary and critical treatment. Possibly, on a “Fee Basis.” And, it would be at a substantial cost savings to our Government. Why is it costing us in both our physical well-being and anguish when it would cost our Government in essence nothing to take care of us here in Mainland Southeast Asia?