Helicopter, Recliner, or Harrier Parent?
May 18 2012
With three kids ages 10, 13 and 15, parenting issues are a great interest to me. So, I thought I’d pass along my observations on a trend I’ve been reading a lot about lately (and experiencing it sometimes as a university faculty member).
It appears that American parents have a tendency to hover over their kids – so much so that we’ve now got a term for it: a helicopter parent. From sports to academics, parents can get a bit too involved in their kids’ activities instead of letting the little ones do their own thing. There was a Tank McNamara cartoon that showed a group of kids telling their parents that the kids were going to the park to play baseball on their own. The parents are responding with accolades about the kids finally playing by themselves, free of coaches and parents, how good this will be for them, and telling the kids to have a good time. In the next panel, the parents are shown running to the park with worried expressions and bringing snacks, equipment, first aid kits, etc.
I thought of this cartoon when we lived in Germany. At soccer tournaments, the American team would always have a mom would bring out snacks and juice boxes after a game while the kids on the German teams were left to their own accord to run the snack stand for a brat or French fries (I usually beat them to it though).
The hovering topic came to mind again when I ran across a test to determine if one is indeed a helicopter parent.
Here is the quiz if you’re curious about your hovering habits.
After taking the quiz though, I think a little hovering is okay. For instance, one question asks about a science project and if the parent does the project; helps out; or, does nothing because it’s the kid’s project, not the parent’s. Frankly, I don’t see a problem with helping out. Mary Claire and I help our kids with their projects. Mind you, we don’t do the work for them (the math and science are above me anyway). But, if we see a mistake, we’ll tell them to review the problem. Or, we get asked to quiz them on their study guides. Or, we’ll just do our work along with them.
My dad would have checked off the last option for the question. I grew up in the 70s, and my dad would come home from his job as Branch Manager for an insurance company; have me turn on TV while he changed (it remained on all night – even through dinner: maybe this is why I don’t like television); have me make his Martini; then settle into the Lazy-Boy recliner for the evening (in that era, businessmen did not bring work home). If I wasn’t hanging out with Jim Salveson or Guy Drake in front of the house (that was really productive), I would go off to do my homework by myself. I guess one would call my dad a recliner parent.
However, as a parent now, the recliner parent seems as bad a choice as helicoptering. I enjoy knowing what my kids are studying, as well as reinforcing to them that knowledge and good grades are like, you know, good things (especially if they desire to attend an expensive college where they’ll need a scholarship).
So, we parents should pick a spot between being a helicopter parent and a recliner parent. Some involvement isn’t bad – we remain involved so that kids come to us for answers, and kids will still learn to be self-reliant. Maybe I’m a Harrier jet parent – I can hover and check things out, then land like a helicopter if I want to. Plus, those Harriers are pretty cool machines.
P.S. Take the quiz and let me know where you rate – do you helicopter or not?
