In Light of The Super Bowl: Athletics Vs. Academics
Feb 03 2012
I woke up today to be hit with two things. First, IT IS SNOWING! We have a blizzard here in Colorado. School is cancelled, my son’s debate tournament in Denver is cancelled – about the only thing not cancelled is me having to plow the snow.
The other item that hit me is our cultural icon: sports! We’ve got the local papers highlighting Tim Tebow at the Super Bowl (not playing of course). We also had a big section in the local sports page about National Signing Day, where high school athletes announce what college they’ll be attending to play their sport.
Now, we’ve been in the States for a while, but one aspect of Americana that continues to smack me is our emphasis on sports. I am always amazed and intrigued by it because it is much greater than I remember either from my high school days or when we first went overseas.
As I read the adulation toward the high school athletes who got scholarships, I feel good for them. One local athlete goes to my son’s high school and he got a full ride to Bradley for soccer. This boy is a heck of a kid! Mature, personable, smart – he deserves all he got.
On the other hand, I realize we never read of the non-athletes who are getting scholarships – the kids who pull a strong GPA, make Eagle Scout, do extra-curricular activities: all toward trying to have as many college options as possible. It would be nice if the local paper celebrated these kids as well as the athletes.
Reading and knowing about students who earned non-athletic, tuition-free college rides would be inspirational to most parents and students since most kids aren’t going to get an athletic scholarship. Plus, it would help parents and students understand what they need to do to get scholarships or grants.
But, the nature of sports may be too ingrained for this to happen. Sports tend to override non-athletic interests. For example, the local university gave a football scholarship to a kid who was just kicked out of his high school for months of racist and sexually overt tweets.
I guess he’d never heard of that adage: if you can’t say it at the dinner table, don’t say it. These tweets were really bad – I don’t even want to link to them (one has to wonder though – where were the parents and how did the kid come to think that these comments were okay?).
However, to the coach’s credit, he did justify the scholarship offer because as an African-American he feels compelled to be a mentor to African-American youths and give the kids proper guidance. I grant him that, and think that is very admirable. However, the cynic in me wonders what mentoring would have happened if the kid wasn’t a blue-ship recruit or an athlete at all.
I also thought about our culture’s sports emphasis when I struck up a conversation with another dad the other day. In the course of friendly “dad” type conversation, I asked if his kid played soccer. His blunt reply was, “He plays competitive club.” Oh, okay – I didn’t ask about that aspect exactly, but he felt compelled to let me know. So then, along these lines (I’ve asked both my readers this before, but I’ll do so again):
In our culture would it be acceptable for parents to be equally open about their kids academic achievements, such as being in Junior Honor Society or getting 4.0 as our society is about youth athletic accomplishments?
I’m intrigued by this question as my kids get older and are participating in athletic and academic activities.
Now I have to go figure out whether to root for Eli Brady or Tom Manning. Hold it, did I get that right? When is the game anyway?


